Skip to content
Help CenterOpen Grongy
English

Writing · Document tools

Working with your advisor and reviewers

Your advisor comments on your draft, you fix the text and write a note, and your advisor accepts the fix. When a paper comes back from a journal, you answer the journal reviewers’ comments the same way.

  • WhereShare, at the right of the ribbon
  • PlansPlus and Pro
  • Your advisorSigns in to comment
  1. Click Share at the right end of the ribbon. The Share with your advisor window opens.
  2. Under Access level, choose Anyone with the link. Grongy creates the link when you make this choice.
  3. Under What they can do, choose the permission: Can view, Can comment or Can edit.
  4. Click Copy link and send the link to your advisor.

The three permissions work like this:

  • With the Can view permission, your advisor reads the draft. No account is needed for that.
  • With Can comment, your advisor signs in to Grongy, selects a passage and leaves a comment. Your text stays as you wrote it.
  • With Can edit, your advisor signs in and edits the shared copy. Your advisor’s changes reach you as tracked changes the next time you open the document; you accept or reject each one as Comments and changes describes.

The link shows your draft as it was when you shared it. To show your later edits, click Update snapshot to your latest edits in the window.

Each of your advisor’s comments carries a status in the Comments panel: Not addressed yet, Addressed by the author or Accepted by the reviewer. The reviewer in that last status is your advisor. Moving a comment from the first status to the second is up to you:

  1. Fix the passage the comment points to.
  2. On the comment, click Mark as addressed.
  3. Write a short note in the Your note: what you changed and why box and click Save as addressed.

When your advisor opens the link again, they see what changed and read your note; if the fix works for them, they accept the comment. If you deleted the passage entirely, you can save the comment as removed. Comments your advisor accepted leave the list; to see them again, click Show accepted.

Journal reviewers don’t comment on your draft through a link; they send their comments in the journal’s decision letter. Grongy splits that letter into separate comments, and you tie each answer to a change in your text.

  1. On the Review tab, click Reviewer responses.
  2. Paste the decision letter with the journal reviewers’ comments and click Split into comments. Grongy splits the letter into comments and groups them by journal reviewer. You can edit or delete the comments and add one it missed.
  3. For each comment, select the passage it concerns in your document and click Attach the selected passage.
  4. In the Your response to the reviewer box, write what you did, or why the text stays as it is.
  5. If you changed the text, click Mark as changed. If you didn’t, click Answer without a change.
  6. Once every comment has an answer, click Copy the response letter or Download as Word.

The panel also flags what’s still missing, such as Changed, but no response written or Answered without a change, but without a reason. If the journal asks for a second revision, click New round.

Does my advisor need a Grongy account? Not to read your draft. To comment or edit, they need to sign in to Grongy.

How do I stop sharing? In the Share with your advisor window, change Access level to Only you can access. You can also turn off every link you’ve shared, one at a time: go to Settings → Privacy & data → Shared links, click Manage and then Stop sharing.