# Citation check

> Check whether your sources really support your claims, how reliable your source records are, and where your literature has gaps.

Grongy Guide · https://docs.grongy.co/citation-check/ · All pages: https://docs.grongy.co/llms.txt

You compare your citations with the sources' own text, find errors in their records and look for evidence for a claim. These tools sit in the **Sources**, **This sentence** and **Overview** groups of the ribbon's **Review** tab. The checks look at the sources in your library; **Find evidence** also uses scholarly search, and **Source integrity** also uses academic indexes. A source goes into your text only if you approve it.

*(Screenshot: The Review ribbon: Document, Sources, This sentence and Overview groups)*

## Check citations

This check compares every cited sentence in your text with the cited source's own text: its PDF pages in your library and its abstract. It does not look at an AI-written summary of the source.

1. In the [Review your thesis](https://docs.grongy.co/review-thesis-panel/) panel, choose the scope (**Selected text**, **This section** or **Whole thesis**).
2. On the ribbon, click **Check citations**. In the panel, the same check is called **Sources & citations**.
3. The panel lists the citations that have problems. Each card holds a verbatim quote from the source (**Verbatim from the source**), the page number and how confident the check is. **Show in source** opens the PDF at that page.

Each result gets one of these labels:

- **Claims more than the source shows**
- **The source says something different**
- **The source says the opposite**
- **The source does not support this**
- **Not enough of this source is indexed to check**

In a text with many citations, Grongy first checks the claims a reader will test first, then a sample spread across the whole document. The panel tells you how many it checked.

> **Tip:** Grongy cannot check a source that has no abstract or full text. Add the source's PDF to your library and the check becomes much more reliable.

## Source integrity

**Source integrity** looks at the records in your library for the whole document and finds:

- Retracted publications, and preprints that may not have been peer reviewed.
- The same publication saved more than once in your library.
- Records missing the author, year, journal or DOI, and records whose year lies in the future.
- DOIs that lead to a different publication, and sources whose card details do not match the index record.
- Citations in your text with no match in the library, and sources you never cite.

A record that open indexes cannot find is not necessarily made up. This happens often with books, reports and journals in local languages; compare the reference details with the publication itself.

## Verify claim

Put the cursor in a sentence or select it, then click **Verify claim** in the **This sentence** group. The **Claim check** card that opens shows, for each source the sentence cites:

- The verdict: **Supported**, **Partially supported**, **Unsupported**, **Contradicted** or **Unable to verify**.
- **Evidence**: a verbatim quote from the source, with its page. The **Grongy's reading** below it is an interpretation, not evidence.
- A **Suggested revision**, if there is one. Put it into the text with **Add as tracked change**, or take it with **Copy**.

If your library holds no evidence for the claim, the card offers four ways forward:

- **Search for evidence**
- **Rewrite claim**
- **Leave uncited**
- **Remove claim**

If the sentence cites no source from your library, Grongy goes straight to searching for evidence.

## Find evidence

With the cursor in a sentence, click **Find evidence**. Grongy looks for sources for this claim, first in your library and then in scholarly search, and groups what it finds as **Supporting**, **Contradicting** or **Mixed or unclear**. Each result carries a tag that shows where it came from: **In your library** or **From scholarly search**.

- **Add to library** only saves the source to your library.
- **Attach as evidence** saves the source to your library and also puts its citation at the end of the sentence.

If Grongy finds nothing, it does not make up a source; it suggests that you rewrite the claim, leave it uncited or remove it.

## Resolve borrowed citations

If you cited a work you have not read and only saw named in another article, that is a borrowed (secondary) citation. **Resolve borrowed citations** looks up the reference details of these works and saves them as secondary sources. If the author and year do not match, it does not add the record, and it tells you how many it could not find.

## Literature gaps

**Literature gaps** in the **Overview** group shows gaps by counting through your library and your text; it does not use AI. Findings like these can come up:

- **Most of your library is more than ten years old**
- **One author dominates your library**
- **A section with little evidence**
- **A cited source contradicts your text**
- **A kind of study your library lacks**

Some findings also come with a **Search papers** button. This tool cannot know about literature you have not added to your library.

## Frequently asked questions

**Does the citation check prove the source is right?** No. The quote comes from the source's own text, but the assessment is a model's reading. For important citations, open the PDF and read it yourself.
